A recent $28,000 Draper, Utah roof was denied. The insurance company said it did not have enough damage, then later agreed to a full replacement. We got to work for the homeowner to properly document the full extent of the damage and prove that the entire roof needed to be replaced, not just a few shingles. An experienced roofing contractor will document, detect and communicate as an advocate for your roofing needs with your insurance provider.
If an adjuster has ever walked your roof after a storm and you later got an email that just said “regular wear and tear,” you know exactly the feeling. It happens more often than not. In areas like Draper, Sandy, Cottonwood Heights and all cities along the Wasatch mountain range, wind frequently works shingles out of place and eventually down onto the grass. When you see a few shingles missing or lying on your lawn, you might not know it, but your homeowner’s insurance is often willing to pay for repairs. Just not always on the first try. It comes down to documentation and proof.
Here is what really goes on behind a denied roof claim, and what it means if you are a Utah homeowner dealing with one right now or just want to be ready for the next storm.
A real Draper example
A Draper homeowner texted us and asked for an inspection after a storm. We came out after a competitor had already visited and found a serious amount of wind damage. The homeowner told us the competitor never mentioned that insurance could agree with the wind damage and pay for a new roof if there was proof it could not be easily repaired. Many roofers push for a cash replacement, either because they would rather not work through insurance adjusters or because they lack the expertise. After our inspection we determined the roof was unrepairable and went over the options. The homeowner decided to file a claim and let us know when insurance had scheduled their inspection.
After about a week, we were able to represent the homeowner during the inspection. After years of experience and adjuster conversations, we have found a common trend: navigating the adjuster visit can be tricky. Some adjusters are dismissive and some are happy to have company on the roof. The end result is the same. Properly documenting the damage before, during or after the official inspection is key. It usually helps to be at the visit, but it does not guarantee approval. Often an adjuster would rather handle the inspection alone and prefers that we wait until they are done. Even more often, a third-party inspection company is sent out to take photos and move on, and a desk adjuster is assigned to handle the outcome without ever visiting.
A few weeks later our homeowner called, sounding like it was already over, with bad news. The first estimate came back with an $800 repair payment, which also fell under the deductible. According to the insurance company, that covered the damage they could see. Case closed. Insurance is a for-profit company and typically will not hand out free roofs, so we got to work proving the shingles could not be repaired.
The insurance run-around
It is the roofer’s job to install a roof up to code without cutting corners. We cannot skip vital pieces and expect old, weathered, glued-down shingles to perform the same as new architectural ones. Patching an old, sun-worn shingle roof does not repair it the same way a new material installation does. Old shingles crack, crumble, crease, delaminate and disintegrate. Some can be repaired, but most cannot. An older style called a 3-tab shingle will normally fail the repairability test and result in the need for a full re-roof caused by storm damage.
As much as we would love to save the insurance company some money, they have already agreed to pay when storms cause damage. This is where an experienced Utah roofer can help. We proved, through video, photos, phone calls and more emails than we would like to count, that this Utah roof was toast. After months of communication, they agreed with the documentation and mailed the next check.
Damaged, denied and eventually approved
A small approval that lands under your deductible is a common first answer from an adjuster, and it is not really a surprise. Their job is to settle the claim for as little as they can while still calling it fair. It is the homeowner’s responsibility to prove the coverage they are owed. Some homeowners do not know they can hire a public adjuster (who typically charges a percentage of the settlement) to point to the policy protections, or hire a roofer to run the repairability test.
It is unfortunate that fear of rates going up, or worry about being flagged for a future claim, stops even experienced homeowners from informing their insurance of damage at all. Those who have had bad experiences with insurance in the past often opt for the band-aid fix or wait until they can afford a new roof out of pocket. But for homeowners who call and hire the right team, many turn storm lemons into lemonade. Storm damage can be, and more often than not is, covered by filing a claim. Read our full guide to roof insurance claims in Salt Lake County.
What to look for before you ever file
A shingle sitting in the flower bed the morning after a windy night, shingles creased from being flapped and blown, or a new look from missing shingles that is almost like a bad roof buzzcut are all worth a phone call before it turns into water dripping through the attic and eventually onto the carpet. If you are not sure whether what you are looking at is a big deal or nothing, that is exactly what a free inspection is for. We will tell you straight whether it is a repair, something insurance should look at, or nothing to worry about. See the signs of hail damage and our storm and hail damage repair service.
Deductible, ACV and RCV explained
Deductible
Think of it as your cover charge. If your deductible is $1,500 and the insurance company decides your storm damage is worth $800, you get a check for exactly nothing. That is how an “approved” claim and a “denied” claim can look identical in your mailbox. Some Utah policies also carry a separate wind and hail deductible, often a percentage of your home’s value instead of a flat number, so it is worth knowing which one applies before the adjuster shows up.
ACV (Actual Cash Value)
This is what your roof is worth today, after the insurance company subtracts for age and wear. Picture a 20-year-old roof as a used car. It still drives, but nobody pays sticker price for it. ACV is the used-car number.
RCV (Replacement Cost Value)
This is what it costs to put a brand new roof on today, at today’s prices. It is the number you actually need, because your roofer is going to charge you for new shingles, not used ones.
Many policies pay out on RCV in two steps: first the ACV amount, then the difference (called recoverable depreciation) after the work is done and you have sent in proof. Some older roofs are written on ACV only, which means no second check. Either way, you are only on the hook for your deductible when everything pays out correctly. Pull up your policy and look for the words “roof surfacing” or “roof payment schedule.” That one line can change the whole game, and it is much better to find it before the storm than after.
From adjuster visit to check: how the estimate works
- The estimate. The insurance company writes up what they think is damaged, measured in squares (100 square feet of roof each), with line items for shingles, underlayment, labor and so on. This is the document that matters.
- The comparison. 123 Roofers writes a separate estimate for what it takes to repair the roof correctly. When the two do not match, we supplement based on building codes and what needs to be replaced. We respectfully request each missing item until all materials and items needed are added.
- The supplement. We will not ask a homeowner to cover the cost of materials insurance is supposed to pay for. A supplement is a formal request to add things they missed: the repairability test results, more damaged slopes, code-required items like drip edge and ice and water barrier, steep or high-roof charges and more. It is usually a stack of photos, measurements and a lot of polite, persistent emails.
- The first check (ACV). If they agree, the payment is issued. If you have a mortgage, the check often lists your lender as a co-payee, which means a signature and a short wait before the money is usable.
- The second check (RCV). Once the roof is on and all supplements are agreed on, the final invoice is ready to be paid. With photos and the final estimate, the insurance company releases the rest, the recoverable depreciation.
No-obligation roof inspection
Here is the truth: the 123 Roofers team would rather be working on our tan than sitting in an office. We like to climb, take photos, tear off old roofs and put new, solid, strong ones on. We take pride in the inspection, pride in our work and we clean up better than the other guys. We catch issues and save homeowners money. There is no obligation and no catch. If we can help, we will, and we have helped hundreds of Utah roofs in Draper, West Jordan, Riverton, Sandy and even American Fork through wind and hail storms. Every home and city in Salt Lake County has seen wind and some have seen hail. When the next storm blows through, or if you would rather be prepared before that happens, give us a shout and we will check things out.
Call (385) 299-3117 or request your free roof inspection online. See our service areas.